Women in the Church

Holy Thursday, 2026

On March 10, 2026, the Vatican's General Secretariat of the Synod published the final report of Study Group No. 5, titled "Women's Participation in the Life and Leadership of the Church". I have become a fan of “Jesuitical,” a podcast by America Magazine, which is run by mostly younger, articulate Catholics, with a very equal gender representation. Here is the link to three of the women struggling with their response to a very disappointing document. https://youtu.be/X-SxGiEQDjs?si=JmuvADu--xxkjfFn. I follow with my own comment. 

I say unapologetically that sex was the reason I left the Jesuits and the Church. Of course, most of the impetus for my decision was the fact that I am gay and refused to take the position of “intrinsically disordered.” But my reasons also included the systematic exclusion of women from real decision-making in the church. After the huge push for synodality, the patriarchy now wants to say that there are roles for women; this is where their power and their status lie; stay tuned.

Let’s examine the flip side of this argument: if a man has talent as an administrator, or churchman, or academic, or an artist, or a poet, this can become a source of their sense of intrinsic worth. If they are good at it, they can make valid, binding decisions with regard to workflow, scholarship, the performance of cultic functions, the value of art, and poetry. Although this is sometimes true, what is more normal, certainly within the confines of the church, is that men, whether a bishop, priest, professor, painter, or wordsmith, make binding decisions not because they merit their status (though some may); it’s because only men are members of the exclusive coterie at the top. Women are excluded.  

You can’t have it both ways. The fact that two millennia ago men ruled and women were relegated to menial positions simply reflects their social status. It is not the universal unalterable order of the universe. Perhaps it is time for the patriarchal church to wither away.

I have written about my personal experience. “Sister Jacinta, the Reality of Women Priests.”

https://jesuskoan.blogspot.com/2022/12/the-reality-of-women-priests.html