Wednesday, September 14, 2022

The McLeod Ganj Psalter RSV

A Series of Poems Loosely Based on the Hebrew Songs of David

With No Apology

Moon Peak - Dharamshala - Himachal Pradesh India.(Dhauladhar Range is a outer part of Himalayan Mountains Highest part of the mountain in this photo is called Moon Peak ) [OC] [1280x757]


By Kenneth Ireland



Dedicated to Zenshin Philip Whalen who loved words more than any man I’ve ever met.

A heartfelt thanks to James Ford Roshi for lighting a firecracker.

Our prayers for David who listened with all his being till the very end. You inspired us.



It takes a village. I have so many people to thank for their support, real help and inspiration for this book. My village includes:


Kumar Abhishek, Akash Patwal, Shivam Nayar, Ayush Singh and Mira Randhawa, all fabulous young Indian designers.


My business partner Hardev Singh, his wife Reshma, their children, Saijal, Tamana, Priyanshu, and Hari’s mother Bimla Devi. 


Harsh Kumar Bhardwaj, Parveen Kumar Bhardwaj, Chu Chu Bhardwaj, Dai Devi Bhardwaj, Sushil Kumar, Jeevan Singh.


Bablu Bhardwaj, his wife Babli, children Aru, Baru, Rinku Bhardwaj, his wife Laltia Devi, children Ashu, Gudiya, and their late mother Subhadra Kumari Bhardwaj. 


Tasif Mustafa and Aqib Mushtaq Watloo, and Tenzin Rabgyal.


James Ismael Ford Roshi, Jakushu Gregory Wood, Rebecca Del Rio, Larry Robinson, Edward Oberholtzer Roshi, Khenpo Kunga Dakpa, Alejandro Garcia de Khype, and Hanut Bal. Christopher Childs, Scott Hunt, Daniel Shurman, Judith Stevenson, and Morgan Zo Callaghan.


Thanks also to Jon Logan, his husband John Paine, their family, and Susanne Zuerbig for their wonderful support and encouragement.


My deepest thanks to my late Uncle Donald Ireland and Richard Rockwell for their generosity.




© Kenneth L. Ireland

September 22nd, 2022

McLeod Ganj, Himachal Pradesh, India


The Introduction

First week: Songs One to Seven

Song 1, Psalm 24, Raise High your Gates O Jerusalem

Song 2, Psalm 23, Following the Flock from Palampur to Chamba

Song 3, Psalm 37, Lady Elgin Becomes a Widow

Song 4, Psalm 137, By the Rivers of Babylon

Song 5, Psalm 90 going on 18

Song 6, Psalm 119, There’s a Boulder in the Road. Is this the hand of god?

Song 7, Psalm 58, A Snake and a woman. This short story has a happy ending.


Second week, Songs Eight to Twelve

It was a dark time and we stayed inside, repeating to ourselves as if we couldn't understand. 

Song 8, Psalm 104: 20-23, On Being Mauled by a bear, a dirge

Song 9, Psalm 119:105, Thy word is like a heat seeking missile

Song 10, Psalm 84:5, The Highway to Zion was washed away last night

Song 11, Psalm 77, Hath God forgotten to be gracious?

Song 12, Psalm 121, Give up all hope until you can't! 


Third Week, Songs Twelve to Eighteen

The Days are growing shorter, and the night is as black as it gets. We still look within.

Song 12, Psalm 139, An Exegesis on the Blackness of the Night

Song 13, Psalm 56, O Captain, My Captain

Song 14, Psalm 57, Indra’s Net of Jewels Catches a Spider

Song 15, Psalm 135, Dredging up Buddha from the Yangtze

Song 16, Psalm 59, And At Evening, Let Them Return

Song 17, Psalm 66:10-16, I opted for the vegetarian menu

Song 18, Psalm 130, "De profundis”


Fourth Week, Songs Nineteen to Twenty-Five

Only light rain today. The monsoon is breaking

Song 19, Psalm 71, Put Me to Confusion

Song 20, Psalm 34; 147, Bablu Called in Tears

Song 21, Psalm 103, Prose & Poem at Jimmy’s

Song 22, Psalm 122, How I Rejoiced!

Song 23, Psalm 109, Saying Yes in The Darkness


Song 24, Psalm 107:24-30, Monsoon should be over!

Song 25, Psalm 104:19, Basho Sings a Psalm



Introduction

Buddhist Koans or Hebrew Psalms? We Don’t Need to Pick a Fight.

“War crimes by one party to a conflict never justify war crimes by another.”

Years ago I was shocked when I learned that the people who venerate the songs of David and claim to have made a covenant with the only One God showered cluster bombs on Qana in Southern Lebanon where Jesus is said to have performed his first miracle--turning water into wine. The party goers asked Jesus, “Why did you save the best wine for the end?” I ask anyone willing to listen if all the singing and dancing coupled with the veneration of the songs themselves as being inspired actually fostered, or at least reinforced this pernicious view that guns, bombs and self-defense killing are just facts of life. If this is the last word, it’s as bad as the first squibbles.

The Israeli attack was more than 25 years ago. Sadly it was not the last assault on Muslim Palestinians. It continues as steadily as the monks and nuns, Jews, Anglicans and even a sprinkling of Unitarians, chant the psalms.

I'm certainly not trying to pick a side in this fight, nor am I trying to diminish the importance of getting history right, or at least as close to right as we can manage, but don’t tell me how to view the fire power or the chants of David’s armies. Almost 50 years ago a Jesuit friend actually learned Hittite in order to reengineer their war songs and distinguish them from what David’s cohorts used to sing to fortify their spirits before battle. A remarkably Jesuit enterprise. I couldn't tell a Hittite from a Canaanite or remember who won, who was more war-like, who killed more people or took more booty. How are we to know that anyway beyond the propaganda of the victor? Anderson Cooper was not around to report the battles, and David, the religious conqueror, controlled the press release anyway.

Catholic priests say the Holy Office every day following the discipline of cloistered religious men and women. I checked. That obligation is still in effect. They read, contemplate, and pray with these ancient songs. What do they do when they come across horrific barbarism? Turn a blind eye? Explain it away as the result of the passage of time and cultural revolutions? That seems to be the response of most liberal theologians.

My friend the Zen teacher James Ford asked me to suggest a few psalms that I felt were authentic and still spoke to me. He was rereading them with an old Unitarian friend who’d suffered a series of strokes. I made an attempt. Both of us had a hard time with so much of the sentiment expressed we both wanted to take out a thick red pen. But following the Zen adage not to pick or choose, I felt obliged to look at the whole body of work, every stinking bit of it.

Read, contemplate, pray. I accept the challenge. However I want to avoid reading from an impregnable fortress of first principles, though that’s often where the psalmist's language leads me, an ivory tower of impervious prayer. I am even unsure about the performative action of prayer. I will try to read them as poetry. What’s also important for me is trying to ask at least a few good questions. Maybe there’s the possibility of starting to think about subjects near and dear to our hearts--perhaps too near and too dear for ordinary scrutiny--in ways that can crack some of life’s puzzles. But it has to start close to our hearts. Thus poems not commentary. This was the impetus for writing my very personal responses to these ancient and revered songs.

Like a good foot soldier in the struggle of Light versus Darkness, I checked footnotes for lines that interested me, and even referred to several in what I wrote. But stories, especially ones with lots of footnotes, aren't worth much if people don't or can't relate. I’ve spent a good deal of time deciding if my reader needs to see any footnotes. When it is important to identify who is Hittite, I tried to write that information into the text.

A note about words and language. I read, think, sing and follow an argument in English. I can also read poetry in French with some ease and know that it feels different. I’ve tried at several points in my life to learn Latin and Spanish, even Greek, but after eight years, I know that I cannot claim Virgil or Ovid’s vision of the world. Only the most dedicated language aficionados claim that poetry is read through a dictionary. I do not use Hindi or Tibetan much at all, much less fluently, but they are the background languages for my reworking David’s songs. Words come through a filter. I only claim my own eyes. But to acknowledge my limitations, I’ve been as spartan as possible in my choice of English words.

As I read, contemplated and wrote, I was distressed that so many people died. It was not planned. It just happened. I told myself to keep writing. Perhaps dawn would break through the gloom on its own. About death--my life here in a small village in the Himalayan foothills is very different from my life in the West. Healthcare is primitive. People die young and unexpectedly. About war--I live in a community of refugees and exiles near the Indian Pakistani border. We are close to the border between Nepal and Tibet. The possibility of war never disappears. The sting of war is still fresh. I would like to think that my circumstance has opened a window into why these ancient songs have endured. Certainly modern Israelis claim that their life circumstances have allowed them to continue to sing the warlike parts of these songs in a way that David’s armies might have recognized.

They say that Thomas Aquinas towards the end of his life gave up the thread of his theological thinking, and turned his hand towards poetry--pretty bad poetry in my view but à chacun son goût . I will close my collection with a riff on Aquinas who, at least in my imagination, faces death with a praise song on his lips.

Raise High your Gates O Jerusalem

The First Song, Psalm 24

7/30/22, the beginning date

 

Today I sing of construction and death

Of making and taking away.  

 

I once heard some angels sing 

In plain chant

“O ye gates; and be ye lift up, ye everlasting doors.”

I sat behind the screen, not allowed

To see the cloistered nuns’ 

Certainly not their bodies, 

But not even the wimpels

That limited their sight to Him Alone

I could not gaze into their eyes,

And had to content myself with 

A soft song of return to the City of God.

 

This was as close as I was allowed to venture.

 

My carpenter called to say 

My doors would have to wait a day.

The father of one of the workers died last night

And he, a pandit, had to attend to the rituals of death.

.

I love Sushil. 

He works well.

His eye is true.

His lines are straight and plumb.

His doors close and latch.

 

Jerusalem is no more holy than my Indian Jogiwara Village.

The nuns who sang so sweetly believed theirs was the City of God. 

Though I never trusted Augustine, I almost did

When I heard their soft cry to the Lord.

May they sing for Sushil today as he lights the pyre to consume this father’s body.

Raise high your gates, O McLeod Ganj, so that we all can pass through.

 

Sushil and his carpenters will return tomorrow. 

Two solid wooden doors to finish.

 

Lift up your heads, O ye gates; and be ye lift up, ye everlasting doors; and the King of glory shall come in.

Psalm 24 King James Version

The earth is the Lord's, and the fulness thereof; the world, and they that dwell therein.

For he hath founded it upon the seas, and established it upon the floods.

Who shall ascend into the hill of the Lord? or who shall stand in his holy place?

He that hath clean hands, and a pure heart; who hath not lifted up his soul unto vanity, nor sworn deceitfully.

He shall receive the blessing from the Lord, and righteousness from the God of his salvation.

This is the generation of them that seek him, that seek thy face, O Jacob. Selah.

Lift up your heads, O ye gates; and be ye lift up, ye everlasting doors; and the King of glory shall come in.

Who is this King of glory? The Lord strong and mighty, the Lord mighty in battle.

Lift up your heads, O ye gates; even lift them up, ye everlasting doors; and the King of glory shall come in.

Who is this King of glory? The Lord of hosts, he is the King of glory. Selah.

 

Psalm 24

 

यह धरती और उस पर की सब वस्तुएँ यहोवा की है। यह जगत और इसके सब व्यक्ति उसी के हैं।

यहोवा ने इस धरती को जल पर रचा है। उसने इसको जल—धारों पर बनाया।

यहोवा के पर्वत पर कौन जा सकता है? कौन यहोवा के पवित्र मन्दिर में खड़ा हो सकता है और आराधना कर सकता है?

ऐसा जन जिसने पाप नहीं किया है, ऐसा जन जिसका मन पवित्र है, ऐसा जन जिसने मेरे नाम का प्रयोग झूठ को सत्य प्रतीत करने में न किया हो, और ऐसा जन जिसने न झूठ बोला और न ही झूठे वचन दिए हैं। बस ऐसे व्यक्ति ही वहाँ आराधना कर सकते हैं।

सज्जन तो चाहते हैं यहोवा सब का भला करे। वे सज्जन परमेश्वर से जो उनका उद्धारक है, नेक चाहते हैं।

वे सज्जन परमेश्वर के अनुसरण का जतन करते हैं। वे याकूब के परमेश्वर के पास सहायता पाने जाते हैं।

फाटकों, अपने सिर ऊँचे करो! सनातन द्वारों, खुल जाओ! प्रतापी राजा भीतर आएगा।

यह प्रतापी राजा कौन है? यहोवा ही वह राजा है, वही सबल सैनिक है, यहोवा ही वह राजा है, वही युद्धनायक है।

फाटकों, अपने सिर ऊँचे करो! सनातन द्वारों, खुल जाओ! प्रतापी राजा भीतर आएगा।

वह प्रतापी राजा कौन है? यहोवा सर्वशक्तिमान ही वह राजा है। वह प्रतापी राजा वही है।

 

Following the Flock from Palampur to Chamba

The Second Song, Psalm 23


We don’t know jack shit about sheep, herds or shepherds, but, despite this glaring lack, “The Lord is my Shepherd” remains a perennial favorite.

The Gaddi were nomadic until they learned to drive taxis, clean and cook for the Tibetans who landed in their hill station little more than 60 years ago and the Westerners who followed the lamas into the high foothills of the Himalayas, the Dhauladhars.

Here where I live Gaddi men used to graze huge flocks during the winter. Many still do. Before monsoon and after the snow has melted, shepherds set off in search of sweet grass high up where they will stay until the snows force them once again, along with the lemurs and bears, to retreat to the lower plains where they can interfere in the lives of other wanderers.

They and their sheep cross the main road near Palampur, and head across the difficult mountains until they arrive nearly 100 kilometers north in the Chamba Valley--three weeks trekking. Their favored grasslands are near Bharmour where the oldest wooden temple in the world is found. Chaurasi is said to have been built by the descendants of Greek craftsmen who followed Alexander to the ends of the earth, that is until his army revolted and turned back at the nearby Beas River. I saw with my own eyes the traditional Greek grape motif carved above a lintel thousands of kilometers from Macedonia.

This is where I propose to sing about the life of a shepherd, as far removed from the third millennium before the Savior as the psalmist’s song is removed from the Court of King James.

I sing my sad song about a shepherd 

Who drove his sheep

Across the highway near my house 

And headed into the high mountains

In search of sweet grass.

 

Just two days ago

The local newspaper reported

In remote Rajgundha lightning struck.

70 sheep and goats died.

 

It’s monsoon. The ground soaks up the water greedily,

Fog so thick your path disappears.

Our shepherd sought refuge under a tree.

He and his boys lived but they lost their flock

And their livelihood

In a flash.

 

I wonder if their dogs survived.

There is a fund for compensation 

When tragedy strikes like the hand of god

And the shadow of death covers the valley.

 

I don’t have even a faint idea of 

A shepherd’s life 

in the time of David, 

But it wasn’t Little Bo Peep.

 

 

Psalm 23, King James Version

 

The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want.
He maketh me to lie down in green pastures: he leadeth me beside the still waters.
He restoreth my soul: he leadeth me in the paths of righteousness for his name's sake.
Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me.
Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies: thou anointest my head with oil; my cup runneth over.
Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life: and I will dwell in the house of the Lord for ever.

 

Lady Elgin Becomes a Widow

Do not fret because of those who are evil

    or be envious of those who do wrong;

for like the grass they will soon wither,

    like green plants they will soon die away. Psalm 37:34 ff 


I went looking for a psalm extolling highway robbery. There must be one. This is the way of conquerors, and King David led armies. Lady Elgin sought to honor her husband’s death in a far land behind a modest stone plaque, leaving plaudits in Westminster to his partners in crime. Her husband also led armies.

James Bruce, 8th Earl of Elgin and 12th Earl of Kincardine, Governor of Jamaica, Governor General of the Province of Canada, special commissioner to China, and Viceroy of India, died of a heart attack while crossing a rope bridge over the river Chadly in Kullu, 100 kilometers east of where I live. It was on the 20th of November 1863, so post monsoon, but still the river can be wild. I have crossed it myself, though in a car on a concrete bridge. Photographs show a substantial man who should have had enough sense to avoid scary bridges, but duty called.

He was not the man who stole marble sculptures (known as the Elgin Marbles) from the Parthenon in Athens, that was his father, but he did burn the Summer Place in Beijing, and forced the Emperor to cede Hong Kong to the Queen “in perpetuity.”

I cannot find Lord Elgin’s grave, 

though it is said he is buried here.

Saint John of the Wilderness

is modest enough

For a Saint who lost his head.

A simple marble stone behind the church

Hides Lord Elgin’s sins.

He knew

Sins enough for one man

And was ashamed.

 

Did he ask for forgiveness

Or even recognize them 

For what they really were.

Certainly after Gandhi 

Other people began to tally up the loot.

 

The British forged solid reasons for

Conquering kingdoms

Subduing Mohammedans

But really they were just greedy

Bastards.

 

In a land where the dead are burned

Graveyard stones that could be 

In York or Leeds 

Though not elaborate enough for Canterbury or Westminster

Seem out of place.

 

The weeds grow thick in the monsoon rain.

All that I can really see on the stone that his widow

Set in the graveyard are dates.

It is tended because tourists come and ask

If this is the man who stole

Marbles from the Parthenon.

 

He cannot be charged with the sins of his father

Or perhaps he can.

People talk.

 

 

Wait on the Lord, and keep his way, and he shall exalt thee to inherit the land: when the wicked are cut off, thou shalt see it.
I have seen the wicked in great power, and spreading himself like a green bay tree.
Yet he passed away, and, lo, he was not: yea, I sought him, but he could not be found.

Psalm 137 “By the Rivers of Babylon”

Wipe away your tears, then deal with the closing line.

Wipe away your tears

You survived

Rejoice

You can still taste salt 

In your tea

 

You’re not captive

Yet you cry 

Poor fools

 

Today the rivers swell 

And wipe away whole villages

You remember Lhasa

And weep again

 

Death has that effect

You saved your mother

But other mothers left behind

Died

 

A few still trickle across

Mount Meru

Camps built for thousands

Receive one or two

 

No more god-throne

Hoping that freedom 

Might birth democracy 

Instead a new president 

Gets drunk

And rips up the work of 

Generations 

 

Still we chant Tibet

In hushed tones

It has come to symbolize

Enlightenment of a Buddha

 

We use his name

To call ourselves home

We no longer rejoice

When little ones are dashed 

Against the stones of Babylon

 

If only for that

It is enough

 

 

King James Version

 

By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat down, yea, we wept, when we remembered Zion.

We hanged our harps upon the willows in the midst thereof.

For there they that carried us away captive required of us a song; and they that wasted us required of us mirth, saying, Sing us one of the songs of Zion.

How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?

If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget her cunning.

If I do not remember thee, let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth; if I prefer not Jerusalem above my chief joy.

Remember, O Lord, the children of Edom in the day of Jerusalem; who said, Rase it, rase it, even to the foundation thereof.

O daughter of Babylon, who art to be destroyed; happy shall he be, that rewardeth thee as thou hast served us.

Happy shall he be, that taketh and dasheth thy little ones against the stones.

 

This one you can sing. Thank you Bob Marley. It’s fun.

 

By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat down

Yeah, we wept, when we remembered Zion

By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat down

Yeah, we wept, when we remembered Zion

 

There the wicked

Carried us away in captivity

Required from us a song

Now how shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?

 

Let the words of our mouth and the meditation of our heart

Be acceptable in thy sight here tonight

Let the words of our mouth and the meditation of our hearts

Be acceptable in thy sight here tonight

 

By the rivers of Babylon (dark tears of Babylon)

There we sat down (you got to sing a song)

Yeah, we wept (sing a song of love)

When we remembered Zion (yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah)

 

By the rivers of Babylon (rough bits of Babylon)

There we sat down (you hear the people cry)

Yeah, we wept (they need their God)

When we remembered Zion (ooh, have the power)

 

By the rivers of Babylon (oh yeah yeah), there we sat down (yeah, yeah)

Psalm 90 going on 18

 

The days of our years are threescore years and ten; and if by reason of strength they be fourscore years, yet is their strength labour and sorrow; for it is soon cut off, and we fly away. Psalm, 90

 

The Psalms have nothing

Good to say

About Old Age and Death

Few religions do.

It’s their last chance to convert

The Libertine. 

Fear mongering fanatics were numbered

Among the psalmists.

 

Legend says this writer was David, 

Who died at four score minus 10.

Being generous

And at the outside of his limits

I might have another 2 good years

Before I fly away.

 

I grow old

But damn it

At 78

I’m 18

I don’t move as fast

Or go as far

But my shorter step

And slower pace

Suit me well.

 

At 22

Elliot was full of himself

Moaning about old age.

Couldn’t he get hard?

Fantasyland.

I won't

Roll up my trousers

And go chasing mermaids.

I promise.

 

 

From "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock"

T.S. Elliot

 

“I grow old … I grow old …

I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled.

 

Shall I part my hair behind? Do I dare to eat a peach?

I shall wear white flannel trousers, and walk upon the beach.

I have heard the mermaids singing, each to each.

I do not think that they will sing to me.

I have seen them riding seaward on the waves

Combing the white hair of the waves blown back

When the wind blows the water white and black.

We have lingered in the chambers of the sea

By sea-girls wreathed with seaweed red and brown

Till human voices wake us, and we drown.”

 

There’s a Boulder in the Road. 

Is this the hand of god?

No one had come to work

By noon.

Even at the snail’s pace 

Of mountain life

This was unusual.

Shivam hiked down the slope 

to Sushil’s shop. 

Legs sturdy enough for the adventure

He texted, complete with click  

A massive boulder slid 

Onto our narrow slip of road.

Paths up and down 

Both blocked. 

A car tumbled down the steep ravine,

Trapping a Tibetan family in mud.

The rain had not stopped after it had done its damage.

It was cold and wet.

This was the situation.

 

It demanded a response.

I turned and tried to pray--

The psalmist sees a blocked road

As about lying, law, judgment

And fear.

Throw in some revelation.

The expected response.

I am not startled by any surprise

Or innovation. Certainly

He loves his roadmap to 

The High and Dry.


My path puts one foot

After the other

Perhaps forced to stop

While resourceful Indian men

Dig a Tibetan family out of the mud.

Not the first time we can thank Indians 

In a time of need.

 

Call it anything you like.

The mother was frightened

And grateful when they were 

Able to pry open the car door.

I am grateful.

In the mountain way

We will just drive around the boulder

Until something changes again.

It always does.

 

Psalm 119:29-39, The Message Bible

Barricade the road that goes Nowhere; grace me with your clear revelation.

I choose the true road to Somewhere, I post your road signs at every curve and corner.

I grasp and cling to whatever you tell me; God, don't let me down!

I'll run the course you lay out for me if you'll just show me how.

God, teach me lessons for living so I can stay the course.

Give me insight so I can do what you tell me - my whole life one long, obedient response.

Guide me down the road of your commandments; I love traveling this freeway!

Give me a bent for your words of wisdom, and not for piling up loot.

Divert my eyes from toys and trinkets, invigorate me on the pilgrim way.

Affirm your promises to me - promises made to all who fear you.

Deflect the harsh words of my critics - but what you say is always so good.


A Snake and a woman. This short story has a happy ending.

Reshma Didi told me that she discovered a snake in her kitchen this morning

Before the sun rose.

It was more than a meter long.

Scared and startled in equal parts, she knew it carried no venom.

Still waking to a snake eating carrots in the food locker is unsettling.

She coaxed it into a bag and released it in the forest 

Far from the house.

 

Our story of the blessed garden invaded by a snake

Metaphysical question, predictable answer equals eternal condemnation.

Lying and subterfuge

Condemn us to listen this devil story forever

We believe.

 

There is a small snake temple in Bhagsunag.

The captive serpent is fat and lazy

Plus Baba has defanged him so that

There is no real danger to his devotees.

 

I have not witnessed the charming, but I think that 

It is not deaf to priestly incantations. 

 

This Song of David and the damn snake may not make the world an evil place

But there is little room for making them into

Family pets. That’s universal.

 

Go release your snakes in the forest as far from the kitchen as you can.

Be careful. Change the course of Western civilization.

 

God Judges the Earth, Psalm 58 King James Version


{To the chief Musician, Altaschith, Michtam of David.} Do ye indeed speak righteousness, O congregation? do ye judge uprightly, O ye sons of men?
Yea, in heart ye work wickedness; ye weigh the violence of your hands in the earth.
The wicked are estranged from the womb: they go astray as soon as they be born, speaking lies.
Their poison is like the poison of a serpent: they are like the deaf adder that stoppeth her ear;
Which will not hearken to the voice of charmers, charming never so wisely
Break their teeth, O God, in their mouth: break out the great teeth of the young lions, O LORD.
Let them melt away as waters which run continually: when he bendeth his bow to shoot his arrows, let them be as cut in pieces.
As a snail which melteth, let every one of them pass away: like the untimely birth of a woman, that they may not see the sun.
Before your pots can feel the thorns, he shall take them away as with a whirlwind, both living, and in his wrath.
The righteous shall rejoice when he seeth the vengeance: he shall wash his feet in the blood of the wicked.
So that a man shall say, Verily there is a reward for the righteous: verily he is a God that judgeth in the earth.

On Being Mauled by a bear

Last winter

The bears came down

Below the snow line.

They were hungry.

Word got out that they were four, 

One with cubs.

 

What went through these women’s minds 

when the bear lunged at their face.

They also had a right to go about their business.

I wonder. 

Astonished.

I ask myself if I would be brave.

 

One who lived is a friend of my cook’s wife.

She was up at the well early

To pump water for the day.

She claimed to have put up a fight.

The village was proud.

The strong survival reflex of these mountains.

 

The Tibetan woman on the kora was not so lucky.

The Dalai Lama should have sent a representative to her cremation.

Her holy work was his.

 

The bears are back up in the mountains where they should be

Now we just contend with rain and flooding.


Thou makest darkness, and it is night: wherein all the beasts of the forest do creep forth.

The young lions roar after their prey, and seek their meat from God.

The sun ariseth, they gather themselves together, and lay them down in their dens.

Man goeth forth unto his work and to his labour until the evening..Psalm 104: 20-23



Thy word is like a heat seeking missile

“Thy word is a lamp unto my feet, and a light unto my path.” 

Psalm 119:105 

 

Are words paintbrushes or missiles?

In the hands of a poet, scientist, warlord or propagandist

The same word can kill or be a lullaby.

 

Take the word love, 

Misuse it at your peril. 

Count bodies on the battlefield

Myriads

 

Thy words

 

Hold words with care

Knowing that they can be weapons

Knowing that they will be weapons

When you cross swords

As you will 

It's certain

 

Cradle words 

That will fly 

Into the heart of

Your lover

Sing them

 

Croon words

Into a baby’s ear

With your own voice

Don’t wait for angels

 

Chant words

With your own breath while you can

At least one word one breath

It will cease

 

Ponder words 

Even in a nasty wrapping

 

Leave words alone 

To do their own work

Without you

 

Rip up words that 

Prop open a door

Onto some landscape

That needs to fade away

 

Erase words

Spoken in anger

Or remember them 

Until they lose their sting

 

Check words

That have many translations

Which may very slightly

Or even a lot

Even for you

 

Be generous

 

 

The Highway to Zion washed away last night

“Blessed are those whose strength is in you, in whose heart are the highways to Zion.”

Psalm 84:5

 

There are two roads to my house,

But only one that people take.

In 12 years I’ve taken

The road that loops through the army base

On the other side of the ridge, 

12 times.

 

I don’t even think about the road

That winds straight up the hill.

It’s just there.

 

Then it wasn’t.

 

I woke up yesterday when Parveen called me to say

Our road had washed down the hill

All of it. 

No more buses with kids coming back from school

No more taxis packing weekenders from the bus station

No trips to bank & grocery 

For a few Western items

 

We wonder how long before it will

Be repaired. Rebuilt actually.

A tall retaining wall 

To support the weight of concrete against the 

Steep ravine.

 

My Tibetan painter friend Tenrab says

Two months.

His Holiness rides the road 

He is old and can’t die while they wait 

For concrete forms to set 

And dry

It is the Road to Zion.

 

He might die. He knows he will..

 

I say six months

Even working through the cold of winter.

Even for the Road to Zion.

 

It was there. 

Now it’s not.

 

 

Hath God forgotten to be gracious?

Will the Lord walk off and leave us for good? Will he never smile again? Is his love worn threadbare? Has his salvation promise burned out? Has God forgotten his manners? Has he angrily stomped off and left us? “Just my luck,” I said. “The High God retires just the moment I need him.” Psalms 77:7-10 The Message (MSG)


When Sonam Rinchen lectured on Shantideva

He sprinkled

Stories of his flight into exile

Freedom is freedom.

 

Geshe-la told us about his extreme acrophobia 

Hanging from the cliffs as they crossed the Himalayas.

Knowing that the Chinese were close behind

They had to keep going.

 

He closed his eyes 

And with his fingers

Felt for the stone

Beyond the bridge.

 

He said matter of factly

After long months in Tenzingang 

Several Tibetans took their own lives

Tibetans never commit suicide

But they did.

 

“The High God retires just the moment I need him.”

It makes no difference that your mother or your lama has

Taught you to smile and be gracious

The favor is not necessarily returned.

 

Ruth didn't want to translate fire and brimstone

Geshe-la insisted

He’d tread a treacherous mountain path

To the camp in Assam

He felt competent to talk about hell

He’d tasted freedom.


Give up all hope until you can't! 

Psalm 121

I will lift up mine eyes unto the hills, from whence cometh my help.

My help cometh from the Lord, which made heaven and earth.

He will not suffer thy foot to be moved: he that keepeth thee will not slumber.

Behold, he that keepeth Israel shall neither slumber nor sleep.

The Lord is thy keeper: the Lord is thy shade upon thy right hand.

The sun shall not smite thee by day, nor the moon by night.

The Lord shall preserve thee from all evil: he shall preserve thy soul.

The Lord shall preserve thy going out and thy coming in from this time forth, and even for evermore. King James Version


Give up all hope. 

Then you can't!


They sang this song

While they carted her body through the streets of London


Not a hill in sight.

In reality not one foot was moved.


Shade, smite, preserve

Persevere.


Not today, not the moon

There is no safety.


At least in coming and going

We have common ground.




An Exegesis on the Blackness of the Night

If I say, “Surely the darkness will hide me

    and the light become night around me,”

even the darkness will not be dark to you;

    the night will shine like the day,

    for darkness is as light to you. (Psalm 139: 11-12)

 

I grew up in the country

But even in rural Connecticut

There were lampposts

Every hundred yards.

 

They kept us safe from 

Hidden dangers.

Perhaps a wandering cow

Or a drunken suburban dad struggling to find his door.

 

There’s always something to hide

And something to be redeemed

Protect the stray dog.

 

Here in Jogiwara

Night is night

Black is black.

 

Our very dark sky is just black

Sometimes te moon appears clean and fresh

Sometimes it’s hidden behind clouds. 

 

When we need to light the rocky path

We carry a big flashlight 

And hope that the batteries are charged.

 

Was it was easier before the miracle of 

Electric power?

 

My Aunt Judy loved her job at United Illuminating.

She said the hardest task ever

Was when she rang the doorbell at dusk

To tell his family that their son, brother, husband

Had died touching a hot wire that

Dangled on the country road.

 

There was no hiding.

 

O Captain, my Captain

On the occasion of the Long Life Puja offered by the Indian disciples of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, September 7th 2022

Psalm 56:8

 

Alex loves Tibet like Whitman loved the Union.

Close to adoration

The practice came at just the right moment.

It usually does.

 

O Captain, my Captain

Is a man who lives in a nearby house

And loves his dogs.

 

“Thou tellest my wanderings: put thou my tears into thy bottle: are they not in thy book?”

 

It’s a tenuous journey

“You have delivered me from death and my feet from stumbling.”

The Psalmist has put his left foot first.

 

If at the end of the Path you step into a life

Other than the one you have,

That mistake seems inevitable.

 

Indra’s Net of Jewels Catches a Spider

“who commanded, or prepared a spider, to perfect in the mouth of the cave a web for me;'' Targum commentary of Psalm 57*

 

Indra’s net of jewels catches a spider

What shape is this?

A vast multi cornered trapezoid

Depends entirely on whim

Or a design we cannot fathom.

 

Buddhists with their ineluctable cause and effect

Want to have one step follow another

Like the Gelugpa monk chasing down the cause

To trap an imaginary opponent into adhering to the Way.

 

The spider’s web is just a catcher. 

Indra’s jewels, nestled in the junctures

Signal being

Gracefully caught in the fullness of life.

 

David’s Master of Song

Plays a cat and mouse tune,

Allusion and deception

Coupled with G_d’s grace to save the day.

 

Traps for heady Jews

Who try to sit quietly and contemplate

The tight web artfully strung between the rocks.

 

This song does require a few notes:

*The rabbins tell a curious and instructive tale concerning this: "God sent a spider to weave her web at the mouth of the cave in which David and his men lay hid. When Saul saw the spider's web over the cave's mouth, he very naturally conjectured that it could neither be the haunt of men nor wild beasts; and therefore went in with confidence to repose."

The Targum curiously paraphrases this clause: [from Psalm 57 v2] "Who ordered the spider that wrought the web, on my account, at the mouth of the cave;" applying a later historical fact, which, however, may have had its prototype


Dredging up Buddha from the Yangtze


The idols of the nations are silver and gold, made by human hands.

They have mouths, but cannot speak, eyes, but cannot see.

They have ears, but cannot hear, nor is there breath in their mouths.

Those who make them will be like them, and so will all who trust in them.

Psalm 135:15-18

 

A seated monk emerged covered in mud

Not silver or gold

 

Fourth or fifth century

Old, but not dusted off from Deer Park.

 

His appearance seems like an oracle

Or the answer to the question posed to the Ouija board.

 

Tinkering with water and deserts

The reservoir was made by human toil.

 

David’s Master of Song sounds like 

A Buddhist sage: “mouths that cannot speak, eyes that cannot see,

Ears that cannot hear. 

 

But is he right or wrong 

About no breath in their months?

 

Yes the Statue is very dead,

But the Psalmist wished it weren’t so.

 

He loves a living God.

 

The only part I really like is that the Buddha was covered in mud.

But my liking is liking that does not like.


Notes:

The recent drought has revealed a trio of Buddhist statues on it that are believed to be 600 years old, state media Xinhua has reported. Three Gorges Dam is 578 km from Chongqing, more than a 6 hour drive. 181 m (594 ft) high, holding back thousands of liters of water of the Yangtze. It is an engineering feat. It also displaced at least 1.3 million people and destroyed natural features as well as countless rare architectural and archaeological sites. The dam’s reservoir is blamed for an increase in the number of landslides and earthquakes in the region.


And At Evening, Let Them Return


They return at evening: they make a noise like a dog, and go round about the city.

Behold, they belch out with their mouth: swords are in their lips: for who, say they, doth hear? Psalm 59: 6-7

 

Is Right speech easy or smooth?

Next door they complain about the howling dog.

Hari’s daughter ties her up during the day.


Other neighbors complain. 

It is tough to hear.

Dogs are pack animals.


Early this morning Baba

Paraded through the village to 

A cacophonous drum beat.


He and his friends were

Carrying Durga Mata

On their shoulders.


Blessing rounds and begging rounds.

All the dogs bark, not at all in unison.

Difficult for words to match a tune. Always.


It grows dark now and barking has died out.

However, it’s wedding season

And the loud heavy beats drift up from the lower village.




I opted for the vegetarian menu


Psalm 66:10-16


For thou, O God, hast proved us: thou hast tried us, as silver is tried.

Thou broughtest us into the net; thou laidst affliction upon our loins.

Thou hast caused men to ride over our heads; we went through fire and through water: but thou broughtest us out into a wealthy place.

I will go into thy house with burnt offerings: I will pay thee my vows,

Which my lips have uttered, and my mouth hath spoken, when I was in trouble.

I will offer unto thee burnt sacrifices of fatlings, with the incense of rams; I will offer bullocks with goats. Selah.

Come and hear, all ye that fear God, and I will declare what he hath done for my soul.



The priest was tall, almost elegant, slim,

Standing tall the full length of his spine, 

With a distinguished touch of gray in his beard.

Gestures and smile to match.

He looked almost a bishop with a bright red robe, 

Quite unlike most of the other Nepali men I’d met.


Rama told us to remain inside

For the puja. She sounded rather mysterious.


It was early. The new sun cast 

Long shadows across the yard

Close to the chicken coop.

Wooden table draped in white plastic 

Fire growling in a pit.

All ordered by her order.


I heard the cry of the animal.

It took me to the window

To watch his feet be tied,

Kicking hind legs immobilized, 

Then laid against the plastic covered table 

And a swift knife.

It was over quickly.

He was hung by the rope that had made him an easy victim.

His blood draining into a pink plastic pail.


An acolyte in a white apron 

Finished preparing him for the fire.


The Tibetans made it illegal to kill so close to His Holiness

Even with holy intent.

What I had witnessed was technically a crime, but it seemed

Quite ordinary for first century Jerusalem.

I was complicit.


The immediate cause of the trouble requiring expiation 

Was my friend Carter,

The handsome ethnobotanist

With a collection of insect eating plants.

He’d trapped

Pinguicula, Drosera, Dionaea and Sarracenia,

Fancy names for tricking insects into their poison pantry.

Not to sound too exotic--

He just walked into a shop in Chandigarh, and paid rupees,

But still it’s the most exotic thread in this tale.


He complained about the washroom. It always smelled of shit.

There was a fight. He was expelled. I was never to mention 

The name Carter.

The Venus fly trap would have to kill flies in the washroom of a hostel below 

Where Temple Road meets another path down to Dasha.


Roaming the meat department at Safeway

The difference in price on the tags pasted onto 

The plastic wrap of meat laid out on the white plastic

Trays belie that the animal once lived. 

But little other evidence remains of

Its cries.


When the feast was laid out after the puja

I noticed that there was still singed hair on the skin

Of the legs that I’d seen kicking at the end.

I opted for the vegetarian menu.


"De profundis”

Psalm 130


This “song of ascents” is usually sung at funerals.


They say it was instantaneous

No one ever says exactly how he died.

It happened just about the same time 

As we were driving home from dinner.


They also say that his cousin who drove the two-wheeler was drunk.

That boy lay for days unconscious in the hospital.

No one knows the truth. No one ever will.

No one will blame him openly. That is just not done.


Rumors in our small community

As ordinary as death and being late for work.

Our driver was also high. We left him in the driver’s hut while we ate.

It was festival time. 


Together with my friend Kumar, 

I head to the village to attend

The rituals of death.

They are not foreign at all, 

Though the trappings are. 

He died on Friday

It was Holy Week. 


Just to be there is enough.

It has to be.

Forget religion.

It is all we can do.


In a darkened room, the women sit with his mother.

They hardly move. No one speaks. No one can. 

I know trauma. I watch with my heart.

I bow towards the shrine in a dark corner

With his picture, some flowers.

He was just a teenager.


I turn and bow to his father,

He is the brother and uncle of several of the men 

Who do work for me.

I am connected.

Tears came to my eyes. 


Of course mercy, of course forgiveness,

But you, songster, get closest to the truth 

When you pray the difficult prayer for hope.

Hope is difficult.


My soul waits for the Lord more than watchmen wait for the morning, 

More than watchmen wait for the morning.



Psalm 130

Out of the depths I cry to you, O Lord;

O Lord, hear my voice. Let your ears be attentive to my cry for mercy.

If you, O Lord, kept a record of sins, O Lord, who could stand?

But with you there is forgiveness; therefore you are feared.

I wait for the Lord, my soul waits, and in his word I put my hope.

My soul waits for the Lord more than watchmen wait for the morning, more than watchmen wait for the morning.

O Israel, put your hope in the Lord, for with the Lord is unfailing love and with him is full redemption.

He himself will redeem Israel from all their sins.


Put Me to Confusion

"Let me never be put to confusion".


“In thee, O Lord, do I put my trust: let me never be put to confusion. . . . .Now also when I am old and greyheaded, O God, forsake me not; until I have shewed thy strength unto this generation, and thy power to every one that is to come.
Psalm 71



I will sing a contrary song:

Put me to confusion,

Even my old grayhead,

Go ahead, do it.


Or I will sow a seed of doubt myself.

Relying on the stability of 

An uncertain stance.

Is far too comfortable

Even given my age 

And lack of balance,

Doubt is just more honest.

Even though I might fall.


Let’s look at a few of the points

Pushed by your songster.

You did not take me out of my mother’s “bowels.”

Pure folly.

I prefer Dr. Spock although my mother was not a fan.

She was always searching for

For the traces of 

Some invisible guiding hand

Which always remained beyond her grasp.

His name was Doctor Mack.


You didn’t teach me from my youth.

The Jesuits did that, and

Though they like to think of themselves

As the agents of the Most High,

They rely too much on Ovid and Cicero

To claim pure Yahweh lineage. 


Of course you abandon the old and frail.

If you didn’t there’d be no complaint.

Don’t feed me that tired old line about

Self-reliance when all resources

Are depleted.

Unless you are really Ayn Rand in drag.


A professor of leave-things-alone

Is rampaging in the living room, leaving a mess.

I will look for evidence of course

But most times it is not even 

Necessary, is it?

You said it and believe 

So it is suspect.


I will only listen to the professor of leave-things-as-they-is.


Who am I to show your power?

You can and should do your job

If you even can.

I will not do it for you.

I will not apologize.


Bablu Called in Tears

Psalm 34:18. The LORD is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit. Psalm 147:3, He heals the brokenhearted and binds up their wounds.



Bablu called 

in tears.

I could see tears.

in his voice.

I could feel raw pain 

If he were as near  

as the palm of my hand.

I would have 

Tried to hold him

His mother died 

in the night.


Who can bind up his heart?

Father killed, 

Perhaps murdered.

Now his mother is also gone.

He brought tea in the morning

To her lifeless body.


She had complained of sharp pain.

Her left shoulder had gone numb.

They took her to the

Ayurvedic doctor.

She would not go to the hospital.

Now her boys and her grandchildren

Have a hole in their hearts.


Pain and suffering

Are not democratic.

Not everyone gets to vote.


Prose & Poem at Jimmy’s


The life of mortals is like grass, they flourish like a flower of the field;

the wind blows over it and it is gone, and its place remembers it no more.

Psalm 103: 15-16


The time and place for different kinds of speaking and singing.


It was mid-afternoon when Tara & I started uphill towards Jimmy’s up more steep stairs to the second floor efforts just to be there. More for four poet-activists, exiles and immigrants, reading Tibetan and English side by side. In India English always for subtitles. Could almost be mistaken as native Americans forced onto reservations or indigenous peoples of South corralled into reductiones by my Jesuits. Viewing like a Daguerreotype Dominant culture invades, steals land and resources. The extermination begins. I want to cry.

Tibetans have the upperhand capturing world attention through the charism of their Dalai Lama. Rigorous Buddhism written and practiced for centuries is perhaps more sophisticated than "Black Elk Speaks," but the soft sounds of the Tibetan language; one young woman read as moving as Buffy Saint Marie. Just sounds. A man whose poem "Just Shut Up" lyrical, spiritual, fiery. Our Tibetan Bob Dylan sang a song he wrote, and then sang another with a man who’d never performed in public before.

These gentle people’s fate still and always precarious. Spoke with several afterwards but kept my mouth shut about death and dying. They are aware of peril, but there is a time and place for different kinds of speaking.


You are not the first

Nor will you be the last proud culture 

Devoured by a conquering army.

You know it.

The wounds smart.

No sauve of time 

To gently erode hard memories

No fading into myth

Not yet

Though that process has begun.

Humankind survives.

At least for now.

Sing like there’s no tomorrow.



How I rejoiced when I heard we were going to go to the house of the Lord

Line Up


Determined to hear 

True Teaching. 

I’d come all this way.


Firstly I go to the Security Office

On the Road to Bhagsunag. 

About 60 foreigners at the door.

Though orderly

I take a number and wait.

They check my passport, 

Run it through the computer--

Pass.

Copied in triplicate

I get the badge of salvation

Or at least an entrance pass.

There’s a service charge.

Line One.


I push my way through the crowd

Down Temple Road

Everyone rushes.

He always starts on time.

Jammed up at the Temple Gate

People crush and shove.

The entrance to Heaven is

Nameless and rude.

It’s India.

The turnstile admits one by one

Forcing order.

Line Two can finally be called a line.


I rent a transistor radio

With earphones

Simultaneous translation, 

Mother tongue,

Hindi and Chinese as well

Will the batteries last?

Always questions.

Will I even understand the questions?

Another queue. 

More rupees

For charity this time.

Waiting for my change to be counted

Line Three. 


We slow to single file

For the metal detector

And pat down.

Pockets out.

Men to one side. Women behind.

Monks, nuns, no exceptions.

No smiling.

So close to intimacy 

It becomes impersonal.

Line Four takes time.


I search the lawn for a spot to sit

Among Tibetan families 

Spread out on blankets.

Kids play with cricket cards of 

Muslim players

No line of demarcation here

But the monks higher up sit in

Neat color coded rows

In strange orange hats.

Feathered mohawks in my mind.

We wait for their chanting to end.

Boredom joins

Line Five.


The steps up the throne are few

But steep.

Other hands lift and guide.

That’s universal.

It seems treacherous

The wonder of falling down.

Behind the constant appeal for prayer,

Fear is universal.

It’s a textual analysis

Only slightly dumbed down

To include spousal bedroom fights

Like an Irish pastor

Not missing a chance 

To hit the heart of the matter..

Line Six is a convoluted argument.


Salty Butter Tea

Must be an acquired taste.

Monks fill our cups

I know this is not

Something I can refuse

Even though my gut reaction is 

To spit it out.

It tastes like piss.

I sit and wait to hold up my cup

For just enough to 

Satisfy the bare minimum to be polite.

The boy monk doesn’t care 

What I want.

It’s not personal. He’s just sloppy.

Line Seven spills over.


Stomachs growl, 

It’s also his lunch time

No tiffins for convenience.

Uniformed guards from the

Indian Army come to attention

And present arms.

The admonition about arguing

In the bedroom requires

The presence of automatic weapons 

And live ammunition.

India under threat from the PRC,

That is a dangerous route.

They guide his way to the lower level.

Line Eight is armed and lethal.


Why an SUV to drive 

20 meters to his door?

No crush of crowd.

A smile and a wave

Satisfy the superstitious ritual

To greet and bless.

His stomach must be growling.

Line Nine says it’s over.


We stand up to leave.

The work of religion is done.

The final Line is a prayer

To be delivered from it all.


Today is the end of religion's work--

Go back, all of you, to your homes.

I leave before you,

Eastward or westward,

Wherever the wind might carry me.

--Tōsui Unkei



Psalm 122, King James Version


I was glad when they said unto me, Let us go into the house of the Lord.
Our feet shall stand within thy gates, O Jerusalem.
Jerusalem is builded as a city that is compact together:

Whither the tribes go up, the tribes of the Lord, unto the testimony of Israel, to give thanks unto the name of the Lord.
For there are set thrones of judgment, the thrones of the house of David.
Pray for the peace of Jerusalem: they shall prosper that love thee.
Peace be within thy walls, and prosperity within thy palaces.
For my brethren and companions' sakes, I will now say, Peace be within thee.
Because of the house of the Lord our God I will seek thy good.


Saying Yes in the Darkness


I searched online for a reference 

Psalms saying “Yes” 

I found a course for 17.99 USD

That promised Yes to G_d

In seven weeks

Using a formula

Magic costs

I said No.


Saying Yes in the Darkness

Involves saying

Yes to the dark gods

In no particular order

Yes to murder and assassination

Yes to vengeance

Yes to bankruptcy

Yes to making an enemy’s innocent wife a widow

Yes to leaving his children homeless

Yes to condemning them to being denied compassion

The rotten sons of bitches 

Leave no stone unturned.


I was worried that my songs

Have been too much about all the death

Around us in our small village

But that is saying Yes

Yes, saying yes in the darkness.


We don’t need armies to do the killing

Life exacts a toll before we can even take out our weapons.

We don’t need to hear G_d’s voice

To know whether we’re right or wrong.


Shaken, thin and wounded

I know who is poor and needy.

It is me.

You, O G_d, don’t need to say a word.


I will say

Yes to lovers

Yes to arguments

Yes to cancer

Yes to heart attacks

Yes to dementia

Yes to being attacked

Yes to dying while young

Yes to my own dying

Yes to love.

 

For I am poor and needy, and my heart is wounded within me.

I fade away like an evening shadow; I am shaken off like a locust.

My knees give way from fasting; my body is thin and gaunt.

I am an object of scorn to my accusers; when they see me, they shake their heads.

Help me, Lord my God; save me according to your unfailing love.

Let them know that it is your hand, that you, Lord, have done it.

Psalm 109: 22-27


Monsoon should be over!

From Psalm 107:24-30


These see the works of the Lord, and his wonders in the deep.

For he commandeth, and raiseth the stormy wind, which lifteth up the waves thereof.

They mount up to the heaven, they go down again to the depths: their soul is melted because of trouble.

They reel to and fro, and stagger like a drunken man, and are at their wit's end.

Then they cry unto the Lord in their trouble, and he bringeth them out of their distresses.

He maketh the storm a calm, so that the waves thereof are still.

Then are they glad because they be quiet; so he bringeth them unto their desired haven.



Before forever,

Before the TV weather man or woman,

We relied on the pslamster to tell us 

What was afoot with the sky god.


Staggering like a drunk,

He made up in poetry 

What he lacked in science.

He also pretended. Poor us. 


But we cannot blame the Psalmster

Or a Weather personality.

We are not reliable soothsayers.

All of us none of us.


Yesterday was half September,

Every reliable baba

From my cleaning lady to Harsh the taxi driver

Said that the sun would shine.


They were wrong.


The stormy wind and rain continue to

Drain the spending power of the rupee.

The Hinduvata tries to calm the storm

But their gods prove powerless,


But continue to demand allegiance.

More.

That the spell has not succeeded is never the fault of the gods

But we the people who pray and pay were not good enough.


Our impossible task.


There is no port or haven.

There is no calm, at least not yet

And it will not last.

We are unmoored.

Basho Sings a Psalm


From Psalm 104:19

He made the moon for the seasons;

The sun knows the place of its setting.



Monsoon might have ended. 

Its descent into the cold Autumn breeze

Has certainly begun.


Last night the rain only started 

After darkness had completely

Enveloped our highest peak.


It’s colder.

The sun sets well before dinner

Change shows its face.


When the moon couldn’t show its face.

The only sound was the loud 

Thunder shaking the grass.


The dogs didn’t bark

It was sudden. 

It woke me from a fitful sleep.


Dussehra was just a few days ago.

Hoping that good wins the day

They burnt Ravana 


Just a flimsy scarecrow.

Evil is far more terrifying

Ask the thunder.


Basho says, “Here’s a foolish notion—

      the spirit world is like

      an autumn evening.”

Foolish flimsy Zen.


Harsh drives me in a battered taxi.

He’s played both Bhishma and Parjánya.

He woke up this morning 


Like a snow-covered mountain.

I woke up knowing that something had changed.

I felt it to the bones of my feet.


Wednesday, September 7, 2022

On the 20th anniversary of the death of Issan Tommy Dorsey Roshi

Yesterday was the 33rd anniversary of Issan's death. I'm reposting my tribute from 13 years ago. I am so grateful to this remarkable man.

On the 20th anniversary of the death of Issan Tommy Dorsey Roshi (March 7, 1933 — September 6, 1990)

I was honored to speak during the wonderful celebration of Issan’s legacy on the 20th anniversary of his death at Maitri Hospice. This is a longer version of my remarks. 


Welcome!

One bright afternoon, Isaan was walking down Hartford St. towards 18th with Steve Allen and Jerry Berg. They were headed to the hamburger place that used to be right next to Moby Dick’s, close to the corner. That might not be important unless you want to know if Issan loved hamburgers—he did—but you have to know that Steve is a Zen priest, a close friend of Issan, his dharma heir, and the first Executive Director of Maitri. Jerry Berg was an early supporter of the hospice, a successful lawyer and prominent leader in the gay community.

As they walked, Steve and Jerry were talking about possible legal structures for the hospice while Issan lagged behind. He noticed a bottle lying on the sidewalk and bent to pick it up. Yes, any rumors that he was an incarnation of Mr. (or Miss.) Clean are well founded. But when he noticed that the bottle was rather beautiful and might be worth keeping, he took out the rag that he kept neatly folded in his monk’s handbag, and began to polish it. Suddenly, a Genie appeared! It had to be a Buddhist Genie, a Bodhidharma look-a-like, with a shaved head, droopy ears and a bright robe. The Genie looked at Issan and Issan looked back, a staring match of wonderment. Steve and Jerry turned around to see what Issan was holding Issan up and stopped dead in their tracks.

The Genie spoke the time honored script of genies: “Because you have freed me after many lifetimes of being cramped-up in that god damned bottle, you, yeah, I guess all three of you, get one wish. It’s just one so you’d better make it good.”

Steve didn’t hesitate: he knew his Buddhism and asked to be released from his karma and enter Buddhahood, or nirvana, or the Pure Land, right there and then. Just as he was about to raise his palms in gassho, the traditional gesture of respect—poof, he was gone.

Jerry thought to himself, that was powerful magic. I’m going for it. I’m not getting any younger so how about a great life in a heaven modeled after Palm Springs—but without the humidity—endless pool parties, rafts of handsome men, an eternal nosh that never made you fat? As he smiled and waved good-bye—poof, he disappeared too.

The Genie turned to Issan who was left standing alone—it might have been wonderment on his face, maybe just a bit puzzled. The Genie said, "OK, honey, it's your turn, what does your little heart desire?

Issan didn’t hesitate, “Get those two numb-nut girls back here. We have a hospice to run.”


Del Carlson and Issan, best friends
Tonight we’ve come together to remember Issan Dorsey.

Jana just lead us in an ancient ritual to call upon the powers that guard the unseen world from which we can still feel Issan’s presence from time to time. Perhaps we can also allow ourselves to enter that world tonight to see him, to hear him, and allow ourselves to be inspired and get the strength we need to live our own lives as completely and authentically as we can.

There are many reasons why we might want to remember him—for most of us who knew him and loved him—we cherish who he was for us, the way he moved through the world. We remember the kindness of his actions—and his great one-liners.

For those of us who meditated with him, he inspired us by his depth of his practice—the way that he carried his understanding of the Buddha’s teaching into his life seamlessly. The man who sat in the zendo was not one bit different from the man who had a martini at the gay bar around the corner or who listened carefully to everyone’s point of view during a staff meeting.

For those of us who worked with him, we knew that his projects had heart. No matter how complex they became when we tried to made them real, no matter what problems or difficulties arose, Issan always directed us back to the heart of the matter—love, compassion, service.

For those of us who only know him by having read about him or heard about him, or having worked at Maitri, you still know him. He didn’t write any books himself, but he left a real example of how humans can look after one another with love and friendship. Here it is! We’re standing in the middle of it right now. And that is perhaps the best way to know him, by trying to look after one another throughout our entire lives in ways that make difference and bring us closer together.

Tonight we are going to try to bring him back into our lives as a way to honor him, and thank him, and be inspired again by his vision for home and hospice for people with AIDS.

I have heard more than 100 versions of this story over the years: "if I hadn’t met Issan at the door of City Center or Tassajara, if he hadn’t really hugged me, told a joke, said a few words that calmed me down immediately, I wouldn’t have struck around—I wouldn’t be here today." He was a man with the ability to find those few words that you needed to hear in the moment, words that came from the heart, words that gently cleansed the sting of whatever was troubling you. He was a man with an open heart. He was truly a Zen priest.

He was also a man whose path to Zen was among the most oddball that I’ve ever read about in Zen’s almost 2 thousand year history. Many senior Zen students of Suzuki Roshi have told me that when they saw the bedraggled hippie with dirty feet walk through the doors of Sokoji Temple on Bush, there was never a more unlikely candidate for roshi. Yet when this effeminate, gay, drug-addicted drag queen discovered the path of meditation, he found his life and never turned back.
Issan and me in the garden at Hartford Steet, photo  by Rich Gerhearter

I have moments when a single phrase that Issan said to me just comes up, for no apparent reason. He had an uncanny ability to take complex issues and say what was important in a few words. Some people can only understand an issue presented in its most simplistic form. But Issan’s few words didn’t show any lack of understanding. When I worked with him (and particularly when I talked about my meditation practice with him), I felt his few words go very deep.

And for gay man like myself, part of the large influx to San Francisco of gay, lesbian and bi men and women during the 70’ and 80’s who were, by and large, alienated from the religious practice of our mothers and fathers, a simple, light-hearted message that went to the heart of the matter was perfect. And if it were delivered with perfect timing and some campy trimmings, all the better.

Once at a staff meeting I was fretting over something that was stamped “urgent” (it seemed as if almost every item in my to-do pile had some red flag, screaming “right now,” “get me done”). Issan just reached out, touched my hand and said, “We’re at war. I’ve been at war, and it’s not fun—well not always fun. We can still have some parties.”

Back in 1988 and 89 sometimes more than a hundred men a week were dying from the effects of HIV/AIDS. It was a disaster the dimensions of which the nation as slow to recognize. There wasn’t time, money or resources to do everything that needed to get done, much less do it perfectly. Somehow, I knew that if I could just focus on what was in front of me, and get that done, it usually turned out to be exactly what was required. And for those of you who know me, it’s something I still struggle with. Thanks Issan—your teaching continues.

And the story also reminds me that when you’re at war, you also find out quickly who your friends are. When the epidemic hit full force, after all the political posturing and bullshitting, our community found resources within itself to care for a tragedy of unbelievable proportions. And we were helped by a huge number of generous men and women from the wider community who saw beyond whatever labels were being thrown around then—forgive me if I’ve blocked them out—and stepped forward to ease the suffering of some fellow travelers.

Issan saw Maitri as much more than just a Buddhist hospice, though it was deeply Buddhist to its very roots. He shaved his head, and wore a Soto priest’s patch-work robe, he bowed and chanted in Sino-Japanese, but he understood very clearly that real wisdom, what we call Prajñā, is not the sole property of any religion.

I want to tell a story about the Mass that my friend, Joe Devlin, a Jesuit priest, said in the zendo at Hartford Street early in 1990.

I had asked Joe to come by and say Mass for the Catholic men in the Hospice. It was a Saturday evening, and Joe was due to arrive at 5. I was scrambling, assembling a few basics, actually just the essentials, bread, wine and a clean tablecloth for the dining room table. Issan, who was at the time in the final stages of HIV disease came downstairs in his bathrobe, to ask when “Father Joe” was due to arrive and see what I was doing. After I explained, he said with a big smile, but firmly, “Mass will be in the zendo, not the dining room.” Then he took over and directed all the preparations with the same care that he would have given to a full-blown Zen ritual. He went back upstairs and when he came down again, he was dressed in his robes. He greeted Joe at the door with a hug and kiss, thanking him for coming and telling him that Mass would be in our chapel, the zendo.

Issan and five or six of us sat in meditation posture on cushions while Joe improvised the ancient catholic liturgy, beginning with a simple rite of confession and forgiveness. When it came time to read from the New Testament, Joe took a small white, well-worn book out of a pocket in his jacket, and said that his mother had told him that the story he was about to read contained all the essentials for a true Christian life.

Then he read from the gospel of Luke, chapter 11, the parable of the Good Samaritan. For any of you who need a refresher course in New Testament studies, this is a story about a man who is robbed, taken for everything he has, savagely beaten and left by the side of the road to die. All the people who might have helped, even those who should have helped, chose to walk on the other side of the street when they saw him—except for the Samaritan. Now the Samaritan in Jesus’s day was the guy whom good upstanding members of the community might have called the equivalent of “faggot” or “queer.” He was an outcast, but he was the only person who actually stopped and took some real action to help the poor fellow out. So Jesus teaches here that real love is shown through actions, not words.

The next morning—Sunday mornings were the usual gathering of the Hartford Street community—Issan began to talk about Fr. Joe and the liturgy. He was exuberant. He had fallen in love with Luke's parable, and Joe. He turned to me and asked, “What was the little white book that Fr. Joe read from?” Startled, I said that was the New Testament. “Oh,” said Issan, “it must have been in Latin when I heard it as an altar boy—or something, but it was exactly how we should lead our lives as Buddhists.” He then said that during the Mass he had the experience of really being forgiven and that the experience had allowed him to feel peace, even appreciation for his early religious training.

When Joe and I had dinner together the night before he flew back to Boston, I told him what Issan had said. A few days later, the small New Testament that had been in his jacket for years arrived in an envelope addressed to Issan. Before Issan died 6 months later, during one of out last meetings, he asked me to thank Joe again for the zendo mass after he was gone. I did. And that New Testament which passed from the pocket of Joe’s jacket to Issan’s spare bookshelf at Hartford Street to my altar, I have since passed on to another person who asked a dharma question about one the stories in the gospel of Jesus.

If I were to give a nice sounding Buddhist name to the next story, it might be something “like there’s nothing too small that you can let escape your attention, even if no one’s going to notice,” but I think that “They never get the pleats right” tells the story better.

When Maitri was on Hartford St., we carried on a full meditation schedule plus running the hospice. One Saturday we were sitting meditation from 5 in the morning till dusk. Issan was not sitting, actually he was in bed and his doctor, Rick Levine, was monitoring a fever that had spiked at about 103 the previous day. That evening, he was to preside at the wedding of two men, old friends, at the Hall of Flowers in Golden Gate Park. 20 years ago Issan married same sex couples in the religious tradition of Soto Zen—long before the issue of gay marriage exploded, Prop 8 passed, was then voided—well, you know that story.

Sometime after lunch I noticed his white koromo, fresh from the dry cleaners, hanging on the coat rack in the hallway. The koromo is a simple kimono style garment that a priest wears under the Okesa, the Buddha’s robe that is worn over the left shoulder. With the full robe, not much of the koromo is visible. It’s really like ceremonial underwear.

I went back to my cushion in the zendo. When I came up stairs again about 3:30 to fix tea before the last block of sitting, there was Issan in the living room, in his bathrobe, with a little head band, and swear dripping from his forehead behind an ironing board. He was ironing the koromo fresh from the dry cleaners. I stopped on the stairs and I had to stop myself from telling him to get back to bed, follow his doctor’s orders and save his strength. I am sure he saw the shocked look in eyes. He turned to me, chuckled and said, “They never get the pleats right.” I certainly wasn’t going to argue with a man who was obviously in a deep state of meditation.

He did preside over the wedding and it was fabulous. Steve and Shunko who were also part of the ceremonial team, came home relieved though complaining about the two husband’s gift list of toasters and table service, “Nothing for the Hospice!” Issan was quick to diffuse them—it was a very special day for the couple who were setting up house together for the first time.

And here is another lesson I learned from Issan, one that took me a long time to digest and one that I still struggle with: there is always enough money to do what you need to do. And most likely, in the best of circumstances, it will be just enough, not a penny more or a penny less. When you are tight, (or if you’re tight) it’s probably time to reorder your priorities.

Over more than 2 decades, Maitri has rethought its priorities many times and revised its budget accordingly. New drugs have increased the longevity of persons with AIDS, and the death rate has plummeted. But new issues have arisen: some people can’t manage the rigorous schedule of drug administration and need training; partners and family who are caring for people with more limited abilities imposed by HIV need a break to care for themselves and thus Maitri’s respite care program and training in self-care.

The new director along with the board will continue to adapt and reinvent Maitri’s programs to maintain the two hallmarks of Issan’s vision: quality care and a true home. This is also a place where we might dedicate our energy tonight: to support them as they chart new directions and promise to do what we can when they ask for whatever they’ll need, ideas, resources and of course money.

In the last year of Issan’s life, a local musician with some spiritual roots had a minor hit. I’m talking about Bobby McFerran’s, ‘Don’t Worry, Be Happy.” Issan loved the song and sometimes would hum or sing a bit of the lyric and then say, “that’s good but I think he should add, ‘Just do the best that you can.’ We aren’t asked to do more, but that’s more than enough.”

So I’ll end my stories here with the refrain: “don’t worry, be happy, do the best that you can.” Issan, you showed us whatever you can do with your own mind and heart is more than enough to make a lasting impact in the world.



And now finally to wrap it up, I’m going to return to my Buddhist joke:

Issan knew that he wasn’t a one-man show—even in his drag days he didn’t perform alone. He was not the Lone Rangerette, or Mary Tyler Moore facing adversity with a smile and disarming off the wall comments though he had some of that quality. Actually if I had to pick TV character for him it would be Rue McClanahan who played Blanche Devereaux in the “Golden Girls,” one of his favorite TV shows. So I can hear telling me, “Ken, be a sweetheart, and thank everyone.”

All of us are intimately connected with one another. The inner workings of an organization as complex as Maitri are also connected to us. As I look at this web, this net, the list of people whom I should thank is longer than the list of names I am going to read. But I will take a few minutes to read some names and I ask you to join me in acknowledging these people and offering them our deep gratitude.

Steve Allen, who returned from nirvana to help Issan (in his case, an innovative temple in Crestone Colorado), represents the many Buddhist practitioners who interrupted their own lives and practice to be with Issan as death approached. They include Steve’s wife, Angelique Farrow, Shunko Jamvold, David Bullock, David Sunseri, David Schneider, Lucien Childs, Zenshin Phil Whalen, Angie Runyon, Paul Rosenblum, Rick Levine, Zenkei Blanche Hartman, Issan's teacher, Richard Baker roshi, Kobun Chino roshi, John Tarrant roshi, Joan Halifax, Frank Osteseski, Ram Dass, Wendy Johnson and the gang from Green Gulch who brought cartons of food every week for the kitchen, Rob Lee whose photographs you see displayed here tonight, Tozan Mike Gallagher and Joshi Paul Higley, men with HIV who were ordained as zen priests, who practiced at HSZC and added enormously to the richness of our practice. I’ll humbly include myself among this group. I began my formal Zen practice at Hartford Street/Maitri Hospice and that has been an enormous gift. The privilege of being allowed to do this work changed my life.

Jerry Berg was a wonderful human being and fabulous leader in the San Francisco gay community. He can stand for all the men and women who were not members of the Buddhist community but generously stepped forward into important roles that ensured the success of Issan’s vision. They include, Richard Schober, Will Spritzma, Richard Fowler, George Heard, Jim Hormel, Tim Wolfred, Bill Musick, Tim Patriarcha (who is Buddhist), Tova Beatty, Maura-Singer Williams, Christine Vincent, Lynn, our head nurses, beginning with Jan Clark, and Anne, Visiting Nurses and Hospice, now Sutter-Home-Health, and Glo Newberry-Smith; I want to thank the hundreds of individuals who gave whatever they could afford, whether time or money, Jim Hormel, Al Baum, Jon Logan to name just a few; our volunteers, board members, Traci Teraoka, Sally Anne Campbell, George Stevens, Boone Callaway, Anne O’Driscoll who cooked great hearty meals, Jane Lloyd who cut hair, Bob Gordon and Bill Haskell, and perhaps a hundred more wonderful men and women who gave of themselves to be with our residents; I want to thank all our CNA’s, Gary, Ichto who’s been with Maitri for more than 20 years, Joyce Cabit, who has also been with us almost from the beginning to name just a few; I have to thank the many small businesses that helped with services, like Marcello’s pizza. Friday night pizza dinner was a highlight of the week and allowed the cook a well deserved night off. I also want to include the designers, craftsmen and carpenters who helped us covert 61 Hartford Street into a hospice, only mentioning 2, Alberto, and Juan (Issan thought you were about as handsome as men come), and I have to thank those who transformed the building where we’re standing now, especially Sylvia Kwan and Joseph Chance. You helped Issan create Buddhist heaven.

And finally I want to thank the almost 950 men and women who made Maitri their home during the last months and days of their lives. You allowed us the privilege of being your servants, and walk with you as you completed your earthly journeys. Your generosity taught us lessons we can never forget. You changed our lives.

The list goes on but I have to stop here. To all the many people and organizations who’ve shared and contributed to Issan’s vision over nearly 25 years, our heartfelt thanks.

Thank you all for your kind attention. Thank you, Issan. As is said in the traditional closing prayers for celebrations like this: May the teaching of your school go on forever. May all beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering.

To read more reflections about the life of Issan, see some photographs, read his dharma talks, go to my Record of Issan page.

Saturday, September 3, 2022

Indra’s Spider Web

I’m wondering if Indra’s Net of Jewels is designed to catch spiders, flies, even wasps, while it at the same time drawing the captivating picture of a vast universe that gives us life, connects all of us, the good bad and indifferent, allows us to support one another, and, most importantly, makes our practice possible.

I started following the blog of a Zen teacher in Boston. I will leave out her name as I am going to be fairly critical. I do not know her personally, have not engaged with her about what I am going to discuss, nor am I out to stir up any more controversy than’s already swirling around, but if you’d like to review her writing yourself, I will direct you to her blog.


It’s sadly a familiar story. The woman is a practice leader with more than a few years of solid practice under her belt. She witnessed sexual misconduct at close range, most of which has become public knowledge. She also asserts there were financial shenanigans as well as more insidious psychological manipulation. She states that she’s not been personally harmed by the insult other than losing a few bucks. 


I do not want to make light of her concerns, and I am certainly not out to condone any of the behaviors. However I began to feel a concern that deepened the more that I read. 


My basic question, shared by most of the people I talk with, is what is the best, most productive and least harmful position we can take in the face of these kinds of behaviors? They reoccur often enough and show no signs of disappearing or fading away anytime soon. I will not sit idly by as if nothing happened, nor can I let it strangle my practice or that of my friends.


I am entirely sympathetic to the loud, and seemingly unending repetition of any complaint when the conditions have not disappeared or even really been addressed. Sometimes it feels like screaming into the wind given the persistence of the misogyny prevalent in the Eastern cultures of most of our first teachers compounded by the male dominance in early American Zen. I have heard from so many people who did serious meditation practice at the San Francisco Zen Center that they were always encouraged by the steady presence and teaching of Katagiri Roshi. They recalled something he’d said to them at some difficult point in their practice that made a world of difference, and they regret that he’d received such a “bad rap” to quote one male priest. The mitigating factor, they claim, is that he came from Japan where dalliances of priests, even married priests with married women, were simply a cultural artifact as long as absolute discretion was observed. These people want to leave untouched the fact that Katagiri was a gifted teacher who helped many people selflessly and so they resort to backwards somersaults to excuse sexual misconduct. That just doesn’t fly anymore--if it ever did.


The situation has not ended with the elevation of many women teachers of the Way. Even though it is a loaded word, I say “elevation'' for reasons that I hope become clear if I can lay out my argument convincingly. It indicates the acquisition of some higher state or knowledge that is unavailable to those of us who remain lower down the ladder. I also want to pay close attention to the fact that it is mainly women who have sounded the alarm, and called for setting boundaries. I want these voices to be heard. However, I have to add that I was sexually abused, raped, by a closeted gay man who claimed the role of spiritual leadership, so the voices are not just women’s. I have spoken out, but what’s the expression? Crickets. There are still lots of people who make their livelihood exploiting this New Age teacher’s reputation. For the record, Bob Hoffman was not Buddhist; in fact his vehement knee jerk position for anyone but himself was anti-guru, not just anti-Buddhist. That position could not save him from being a predator and a simple criminal. But before I stray too far afield, I want to stay focused as much as I can on the response of the Buddhist sangha to sexual misconduct.


There is also nothing at all wrong about this teacher’s main argument that Buddhist teachers can’t escape the ethical implications of setting and respecting boundaries with students. It comes with the territory. Of course. She uses the professional norms for therapists who do not have sexual relationships with their patients, do not exchange money outside an agreed upon fee structure, and do not interfere in their intimate relationships between friends, lovers and family. My impression is that she saw some violations of these boundaries, and suspected others. This destroyed her trust in the teacher in question, and started her search for establishing clear boundaries for herself and her community. 


These guidelines may crimp the style of some teachers who want to push a student to examine all the nooks and crannies of his or her inner workings. Sometimes, dare I say often, even hopefully, every seemingly bizarre personal quirk, hidden agenda or blindly held prejudice comes up for scrutiny in meditation practice, but the role of the psychotherapist and meditation mentor are quite different. I hesitate to make any pronouncements, but the aim of the therapist might be to alleviate the pain of maladjustment while the meditation teacher’s role might be to just point to it so that the student can sort things out for themselves, or not. 


A very intelligent homeless man came to the meditation group I organized in the San Francisco Tenderloin every Tuesday night for several years until I drove him away in hopes of persuading him to find shelter. I tried to rigorously honor the boundaries of my role as the person who opened the door, set out the cushions and watched the timer to just that, but I made what I still consider a grave mistake. 


This man was a serious student of the Talmud and Primo Levi, packing a small library while living outdoors. His former wife was an Episcopal priest. He didn’t fit my profile of a homeless man. One night after meditation I sat with him and grilled him. I am embarrassed to admit it. He tried to defend himself by speaking of the virtues of living outside, even in the cold and rain, but I wasn’t buying it. He stopped coming to the zendo. I could not locate him. I was devastated.


Perhaps the teacher of boundaries is just concerned that no wild, crazy wisdom teacher breaks up the china shoppe. After reading I was left with the impression of a woman who has an orderly mind, academically and scientifically trained. I sympathize with her. Surely people like that, and I include myself, can be open to the unexpected stabs of enlightenment. I hope so.


But I left with the feeling, perhaps it was just her emphasis, that though everything is entirely right with her position, everything is entirely wrong. She states that every teacher relationship is prey to these violations; that every teacher will eventually do you wrong, rope you in, manipulate you, seduce you or violate your emotional boundaries. We’ll leave the sex part out, but it is certainly included. You can trust no one. She has followed the logic behind her assumptions to its inevitable conclusion: the sangha, the treasure that we are told the Lord Buddha valued above all others, is untrustworthy. It cannot do the job. 


But what if it is doing its job without manipulation? What if it’s meant to be imperfect? What happens when we posit that the Buddha was right? That the sangha does its job. That it has to be trusted. Indra’s net levels the playing field. Teachers are not elevated above its finely stretched web. There are no high wires to trip up the high and mighty. They catch us all. It can be trusted to do its job.


And once you’ve caught the spider, what do you do? Some scream, some cry foul. Some struggle. Some set up new boundaries as an extra precaution. We’re all assholes and we got caught. We pick up the  pieces and repair the net. We cradle the wounded and cremate the dead.


Tōsui Unkei is a well-known 15th century Zen teacher who lived under a bridge in Kyoto. There’s a koan about him but I could not locate it in any of the standard collections. From what I can glean from the unofficial commentary, it seems to be about living with whatever gifts life offers us, no matter whether they're robes or rags. Here is the verse attributed to him when he left the monastery to live the life of a homeless beggar.


Today is the end of religion's work--

Go back, all of you, to your homes.

I leave before you,

Eastward or westward,

Wherever the wind might carry me.


I missed it. I also didn't honor my own boundaries. I’m sorry. I dedicate this work to you, my homeless Tenderloin Zen student wherever you ended up.


Friday, September 2, 2022

The Ethical Slut goes in search of a Zen teacher

I had an email exchange with a well-regarded senior Zen teacher from the same lineage as I practice in. Our conversation quickly veered off into a dead end, and I was left wondering what I’d said wrong. I am going to talk about some private communication so I will not name names, but I don’t have to flesh out the full context of our exchange. I was not teacher-shopping. I simply asked a question. 


Roshi X asked me whom I practiced with. My answer included some of the most senior teachers in his school and some well known people in another lineage. I’ve been practicing Zen since 1988, and for most of that time have talked with a teacher both on retreats and at regular intervals. I’ve made the formal request to train with several different teachers, but it was always serial monogamy, never two at once. Four of my teachers are dead, two died while I was working with them; one sent me to his senior student and then died. One died after I began koan work. We parted on very friendly terms, but I think she was happy to be rid of me--another tale.


Rigid Roshi came down on me like a ton of bricks. After questioning the credentials of several of the teachers I mentioned, he asked how could I expect to make any real progress unless I found my master, stuck it out, drilled down and got to the heart of the matter? I may be generalizing a bit, but that was the tone. I was looking for a place to do retreats near to where I live, but quickly decided that it would not be with the Rigid Roshi. 


Yesterday a Zen friend asked me why we need teachers anyway? A good question. It is of course pretty standard practice in Zen to seek out a teacher at some point. I’ve heard the tired old saying that when you’re ready the teacher will come to you. I like the mystical lyricism of the sentiment. It even has a touch of magic, but there’s definitely a lot more involved. Usually something happened on the cushion that made you want to go deeper, some experience caught you off guard and merited further exploration, perhaps you just wanted someone to talk to as you venture into unfamiliar territory, or maybe you got lucky and met someone you clicked with, a true dharma friend. I can locate some or all of those motivations in my own search for teachers at various times. For the most part I’ve always had a teacher over the nearly 50 years I’ve practiced. I do better when I have one. I’m more focused, more happy. I actually encountered Buddhism when I met someone whom I could really call a Buddhist. I’d read a few things but then I set out to meet a teacher. Although I didn’t ever formally become his student, I visited this very experienced meditation practitioner many times over the years, listening to him, asking him questions, participating in his practice and observing how he behaved. So I’m prejudiced. I’ve had several connections with other men and women who were solid practitioners. I've been lucky. They were very decent human beings. There was a connection. It can go deep.


But to get back to Rigid Roshi’s criticism. Why just one? Where does that lead? What kind of relationship is required? What are the boundaries? What happens if it becomes a tired old stale relationship like a dead marriage, or what, and this is not unknown, what if becomes abusive? What is the value? What if when you haven’t found true love, you play the field and sleep around? Like many westerners I’ve sampled from various traditions. I’ve spent time in at least two Tibetan traditions, or at least spent untold hours studying, going to classes, even seeking refuge and receiving empowerments. I’ve done vipassana retreats, and read their literature. I’ve worked with four Soto teachers, done many sesshins, lived in practice centers. I’ve done koan practice with at least 6 authorized teachers. I’m a total slut. I began my checkered Buddhist practice in about 1973. With several extended hiatus for psychological work, and a painful exploration in the world of drugs, I’m coming up on 50 years of practice. Do I still work with a teacher? Yes. Does it take time to develop a fruitful collaboration with him or her? Obviously. Do I have boundaries? You betcha. Do I recommend it? The jury’s out. But I do know this: in the West we do not have a solid tradition of established Buddhist practices rooted in our culture. As you walk down the street, the Methodist Church might be right next to Saint Catherine’s parish, but the Rinzai temple is not to be found. The Tibetan lama has just opened his center in an old fraternity house, and is very busy, way too busy to give you much individual attention. Of course you’re going to look around for a little love and affection. We’re humans. 


Which brings me back to my original question: How does an ethical slut find a teacher and actually develop a good relationship?


I will be clear about what I want, and what I’m willing to give, or give up. You have to be clear too.

  • Sure it can get down and dirty. That’s the point. 
  • We’re equals in the relationship. There's a lot I don't know. If you have the answer to a question that I’m looking for, I will be grateful if you share it. But that’s it. I am assuming that it comes with no strings attached. If I see tell tale signs that you are going to demand something that I’m unwilling to give, it’s time to say good bye.
  • I don’t do well with either domination or subservience.
  • I do not do homophobia or sexism.
  • I don’t pay for sex. I have but it was over very quickly and in retrospect not worth it.
  • The understanding is that there will be mutual respect, and that nothing lasts forever.


So no thanks Rigid Roshi, I will not be coming around. I don’t even know you and you dropped a load of garbage on me. How can I expect to be treated as a unique human? You do not know something I don’t. And if you are in the business of offering some service to humankind for the benefit of others and a taste of freedom, I can recommend a few practitioners with a little more savoir faire who can coach you in some interpersonal skills.